The Black Hills Preservation Project -- Protecting Our Land and Water Supply 💧
F3 Gold received approval from the US Forest Service for exploratory gold‐drilling (about 36 drill sites) on public lands about 4 miles west of Custer in the Black Hills National Forest. The Mighty 790 KFGO | KFGO+2South Dakota Searchlight+2
The drilling is projected to go up to depths of around 3,000 feet using diamond‐core drilling. South Dakota Searchlight+1
Although current permits are for exploration, local groups fear that exploratory drilling could lead to full mining operations down the line (which entail greater environmental risk). https://www.kotatv.com+2BH Clean Water
How this could impact water wells & water supply
The project is located upstream from watersheds supplying local communities, including around French Creek and possibly contributing to the wider water supply. Some comments flag the risk to surface and groundwater. BH Clean Water Alliance+2SDPB+2
Drilling requires water: in one related document the scale was 5,000 to 10,000 gallons of water per day per rig for drilling operations. UNICORN RIOT+1
If local water wells tap into the same aquifers or connected groundwater systems as the drilling, then there is an avenue for impact: drawdown, contamination, or changes to hydrologic gradients.
Drilling can disturb rock formations and fracture systems; this could enable migration of drilling fluids or contaminants into aquifers if not properly sealed.
The company states they’ll use municipal or industrial water (not local surface waters) and will cap holes when done. F3 Gold+2UNICORN RIOT+2
However, critics say no mine is proposed yet, but exploration is the first step. If a mine followed, then chemical leaching, tailings, acid‐rock drainage could become major issues. https://www.kotatv.com
The risk of surface water contamination: even if the drilling uses municipal water, the disturbance of terrain or sediment could allow runoff into streams, affecting downstream users and wildlife.
Local private wells could be affected by:
Lowering of the water table due to drilling draws or future mining draws.
Alteration of groundwater flow paths leading to contamination or reduced water quality.
If the drilling occurs between a recharge zone and well‐field, the integrity of well water could be jeopardized.
Because the region’s geology is complex (fractured rock, karst, multiple aquifers), the usual assumption of “drilling is small impact” may underestimate connectivity.
Even though the footprint for drilling is described by F3 Gold as “small” (less than 4‐5 acres) for exploration in some cases. F3 Gold+2UNICORN RIOT+2
Habitat fragmentation: creation of drill pads, access roads, staging areas can degrade habitat for sensitive species (wildlife, plants) and increase edge‐effects (predation, invasive species).
Noise, light, and human intrusion during drilling (potentially 24h/day operations) could disturb wildlife behaviours such as breeding, migration, foraging. SDPB
Reclamation is promised: yet the “temporary” disturbance may still have long‐term impacts on soil, vegetation, and ecosystem connectivity.
If a mine were to follow, the impacts multiply: large pit, tailings, waste rock, trucks, processing—all increasing habitat loss, dust, noise, and ecosystem stress.
Tourism & recreation: The Black Hills is a major recreation area. Surface disturbance from drilling may reduce scenic quality, access, and thereby local tourism economy. https://www.kotatv.com
Cumulative effects: While one exploratory drilling may seem small, multiple operations over time create cumulative habitat loss, increased road density, erosion, and hydrologic change.
Cultural & Indigenous concerns: Some local tribes and cultural groups argue that proper consultation has been lacking and that sacred or culturally significant lands may be affected. BH Clean Water Alliance+1
Uncertainty about future mining: The exploration may not lead immediately to mining, but it opens the door; many community members fear that once exploration is done, mining may follow with far greater risk.
F3 Gold states that drilling is “small‐scale, limited impact” and that no mining or processing is part of the current permit. F3 Gold+1
Company states water for drilling will be sourced from municipal/industrial sources (not local surface waters) and drill holes will be sealed/plugged after use. UNICORN RIOT+1
They claim the footprint is very small compared to the size of the National Forest and that they will reclaim land once done. F3 Gold+1
Even though the company says “no mining” now, local groups fear this is a stepping stone. (Exploration → discovery → extraction) https://www.kotatv.com
The forest service decision used a categorical exclusion (i.e., no full Environmental Impact Statement) despite community requests for deeper review. BH Clean Water Alliance+1
The downstream/upstream‐watershed issue: Even if the hills only host exploration now, contamination in such a sensitive hydrologic area could impact drinking water supplies for surrounding communities.
Monitoring and enforcement: Once drilling is done and reclamation begins, long‐term monitoring of water, soil, and ecosystem health is critical—but not always guaranteed.
Water use and rights: Even using municipal water, there may be indirect effects on water availability for local wells and streams.
Potential Impacts
Groundwater / Wells
Lowered water table, altered flow paths, contamination of well water
Surface water & streams
Sediment/runoff contamination, disturbance near stream/creek corridors
Wildlife & habitat
Fragmentation, disturbance, loss of old‐growth or sensitive forest zones
Recreation / tourism
Degraded scenic values, trail closures, noise, and access issues
Future mining risk
Exploration may lead to mining which has much greater footprint and risk
Cultural / Indigenous
Inadequate consultation, impact on sacred or historic sites
By Brad Walton
from KOTATV.com
Published: Jul. 17, 2024 at 10:11 AM MDT
RAPID CITY, S.D. (KOTA) - Minneapolis-based mining company F3 Gold is set to begin exploratory drilling for gold west of Custer. The US Forest Service approved the Newark Exploratory Drilling Project June 18, and some nearby landowners worry about the project’s potential ecological impacts.
Those landowners met with environmental activists and Custer County leaders Tuesday night at Custer County Library to discuss the situation and their plans to oppose the project. Lea Anne and Rob McWharter and Gary Placco hosted the meeting, each expressing concern over the idea of drilling contaminating the groundwater.
“This is your water. Every single person in this county gets water from the same place,” Placco said, addressing the crowd of 92. “And if you want to believe for a split second that they’re drilling into the ground 5,000 feet, 390 holes, and it’s not gonna affect your water, don’t talk to me later. There’s something wrong with you.”
Rob McWharter worked for the Bureau of Land Management for many years and has seen similar situations in the past. He said he believes the Forest Service rushed their decision to get ahead of recent federal environmental regulations.
“Any categorical exclusion, decision, that’s done before 1 July will retain its validity,” McWharter continued.
The group authored a letter of petition and protest to the Forest Service, asking for a suspension of the drilling permit until a thorough environmental assessment is completed. If this doesn’t happen, Placco says he wants to file a lawsuit.
“Protest all you want,” Placco said. “You can scream, rave, and rant. But you can’t stop this unless you do it through court. That’s the only way you can stop this.”
F3 is authorized to begin drilling, but they reportedly have not done so yet. More updates will come as the situation continues to unfold.
Copyright © 2025 Black Hills Preservation Project
Custer, South Dakota
Black Hills Preservation Project is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. Donations are tax-deductible.
©2025 Black Hills Preservation Project. All rights reserved.
Black Hills Preservation Project
PO Box 9
Custer, SD 57730
Contact Email: blackhills@myyahoo.com